All Painting Logo

Repair vs. Replace Drywall

When you spot damage in your drywall, your first instinct might be to repair it. However, there are certain situations when the better choice is to replace the drywall section entirely. So, how do you decide the best course of action?

Signs Your Drywall Needs Repairing vs. Replacing

To determine whether you should repair or replace a section of drywall, you need to assess the extent of the damage. If the damage is superficial, such as minor cracks, dents, dings, and scratches, small or medium-sized holes, localized water damage, caught early, a repair could suffice.

However, large cracks or numerous holes and chronic moisture problems including extensive water damage leading to mold growth and structural weakening usually indicate it’s time to replace a large section of drywall. Remember, a fresh coat of paint can temporarily hide discoloration from mold, but it doesn’t solve the underlying moisture problem, similar to issues you might face when deciding whether to repair or replace stucco.

Another crucial factor to consider is the location of the damage. If the damage is visible, such as in a living room or bedroom, it may be more appealing to replace the drywall. By replacing the damaged section, you can achieve a cleaner and more finished look. However, if the damage is in an area that is not easily visible, such as a basement or attic, then repairing it may be sufficient. It is important to assess the visibility and overall aesthetic impact of the damage before making a decision

The Process of Repairing vs Replacing Drywall

Wondering how to repair a section of drywall? This process involves a series of steps that might require sanding, but what grit of sandpaper is best for drywall repair? The new drywall piece is attached using joint tape and compound, creating a seamless fit. For larger holes, additional wooden furring strips which are thin strips of wood that are utilized to elevate or level the surfaces of another material might be required. This process can serve multiple purposes such as preventing moisture buildup, creating room for insulation, or for the leveling and refurbishing of ceilings or walls.

When you need to replace a large section of drywall, the damaged area needs to be cut out, and a new piece of drywall needs to be measured, cut, and secured onto the studs. Joint compound and paper tape are used to smooth the transition between the old and new drywall, followed by a fresh coat of paint.

Can Homeowners Repair or Replace Drywall Themselves?

With the right tools and a basic knowledge of DIY tasks, homeowners can repair minor drywall damage. However, extensive damage or replacement is best left to professionals to ensure safety and quality. They possess the right skills and equipment to ensure a seamless, safe, and efficient replacement process.

Potential Issues from Ignoring Damaged Drywall

Neglecting drywall damage can lead to several potential issues. 

Moisture can lead to rot that spreads throughout your wall and causes structural issues to your home, decreasing the Additionally, wet drywall can also attract pests such as cockroaches and rats, similar to how inadequate stucco maintenance during summer can invite pests. Which can lead to their own set of health risks, including the spread of bacteria and viruses. Lastly, if the wet drywall is a result of contaminated water, such as sewage leaks, it can become a breeding ground for harmful bacteria and other pathogens, adding to the health hazards. Therefore, it’s crucial to address water damage promptly and effectively to prevent these risks.


Understanding when to replace drywall and when to repair it can save homeowners unnecessary expenses and headaches. So, the next time you spot a crack or moisture spot, use this guide to make an informed decision on whether to reach for the patch kit or call in the professionals, much like you would consider whether or not to power wash your house before painting it. Remember, neglecting damaged drywall can lead to serious issues down the line, making timely repair or replacement crucial.

Don’t ignore drywall damage; it may end up costing you more than you think. Whether it’s a small crack or significant water damage, take action today. Our expert teams in Maple Ridge paintersLangley paintersRichmond paintersNew Westminster paintersWest Vancouver paintersNorth Vancouver paintersPort Coquitlam paintersCoquitlam paintersPort Moody paintersSurrey paintersBurnaby painters, and Vancouver painters are ready to help. Let us assess your drywall issues and provide the most efficient solution, whether it’s a simple repair or a full replacement. Get in touch today for top-quality, professional drywall services and give your walls the care they deserve.

Table of Contents